Explore Challenges
- Countryside in Crisis?
- The Energy Water Food Stress Nexus
- Unsustainable Fishing
- Keeping pace with a digital revolution
- Global health in the 21st Century
- Adapting to an urban future
- Educating for tomorrow
- Digital technology in Africa
- Persistent poverty in Britain
- Can the UK ever be sustainable?
- Plastic pollution in the oceans
- Natural disasters: how to improve?
- Not In My Back Yard
- Digital Divide in the UK?
- Importing goods, exporting drought?
- Britain’s ageing population
- Engineering our climate
- The future shape of Capitalism
- Migration: skills and the job market
- Razing the Rainforest
- London under water
- Concreting the countryside
- Future of low carbon energy
- Africa in the 21st Century
Prince Charles, population growth, CO2 Emissions, @Dr_Black, cryptography, plastic, Copenhagen, Flood risk, environment, Obama, population, #21cc, europe, consumption, design thinking, bbc, Natural disaster, genetics, energy, G20
Not In My Back Yard
With pressure on the UK’s ageing energy and transport infrastructures mounting, is it time to put projects of national importance ahead of local concerns? Or does this bypass our democratic right to object?
DAME FIONA REYNOLDS Director, The National Trust
JIM STEER Steer Davis Gleave
ANTONY OLIVER Editor, New Civil Engineer
JULIAN GLOVER Chief leader writer, The Guardian
- TALKS
- FOCUS
- 60 SECONDS
- INTERVIEWS
- NEWS
Introduction by Julian Glover, the guardian
Julian Glover, chief leader writer for the guardian and chair, introduces the topic of the discussion and the panel.
watch video »Antony Oliver - New Civil Engineer
Antony Oliver, Editor of New Civil Engineers, discusses NIMBYism and planning in Britain
watch video »Fiona Reynolds - The National Trust
Dame Fiona Reynolds, Director-General of The National Trust discusses the importance of local planning and the right for people to object to development.
watch video »Jim Steer, Steer Davis Gleave
Jim Steer discusses proposals for a high speed rail network and the way it could transform the economic geography of Britain.
watch video »
Interview with Maria McCaffery
Cheif Executive of Renewables UK, formerly the British Wind Energy Association.
Interview with Ken Livingstone
We meet Ken Livingstone, former Mayor of London, to discuss Heathrow, Crossrail, the…
Interview with Shaun Spiers, CEO of CPRE
Shaun Spiers, Chief Executive of Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE) talks about…
Interview with Wayne Hemingway MBE
Watch an interview with designer Wayne Hemingway MBE on the role of design…
Wind farms: harmless or harmfull?
The debate over wind farms often polarises local opinion. Read…
What is the Infrastructure Planning Commission?
Find out what the Infrastructure Planning Commission (IPC) does and…
Interview with Maria McCaffery
Cheif Executive of Renewables UK, formerly the British Wind Energy…
Interview with Ken Livingstone
We meet Ken Livingstone, former Mayor of London, to discuss…
Interview with Shaun Spiers, CEO of CPRE
Shaun Spiers, Chief Executive of Campaign to Protect Rural England…
Interview with Wayne Hemingway MBE
Watch an interview with designer Wayne Hemingway MBE on the…
Nimbys secure their charter
- Source: The Times
26th May 2010
Local planning policies have been enshrined in the Queen’s Speech. Under proposals outlined by the Government yesterday, local councils would be given financial incentives to promote the development of new homes, shops and offices.
Keep trains out of my 5,000-acre back yard
- Source: The Times
11th April 2010
Lord Rotheschild, the financier and a friend of Lord Mandelson, the business secretary, is leading a revolt against government plans for a 250mph railway line that will cut through swathes of the countryside.
Heathrow third runway opponents win court challenge
- Source: BBC News
26th March 2010
Campaigners have won a High Court battle over plans for a third runway at Heathrow Airport.
Bill Bryson talks to the party leaders about countryside issues
- Source: The Times
20th March 2010
On the eve of the general election, the writer and rural advocate challenges party leaders on the crisis facing our countryside
Councils concerned nuclear assessment hand-outs would create bias
- Source: The Guardian
16th March 2010
Under new planning rules, energy companies pay local authorities to assess their planning applications, but some councils do not have the resources or expertise
Audio: £30bn high-speed rail plans unveiled
- Source: The Guardian
12th March 2010
Panel discusses proposals to run 250mph trains between London and Birmingham
High-speed rail plans announced by government
- Source: BBC News
11th March 2010
Plans for a new high-speed rail network, featuring 250mph trains, have been announced by Transport Secretary Lord Adonis.
New high speed rail link announced
- Source: 10 Downing Street
11th March 2010
The Government has announced plans for the development of a high speed rail network linking London to Birmingham.
Prepare for the fourth transport revolution
- Source: The Times
11th March 2010
Britain needs it and can afford it. There is no reason to hold back high-speed rail
Audio: Consultation ‘the right way forward’ on high-speed rail
- Source: BBC Radio 4
11th March 2010
Liberal Democrat transport spokesman Norman Baker and Shaun Spiers from the Campaign for the Protection of Rural England, discuss how to reconcile the benefits of large national projects with local objections.
No problem pupils in my backyard
- Source: The Guarduan
9th March 2010
Are recent disputes between special schools and local residents indicative of a growing trend in people refusing to live alongside pupils with behavioural problems?
At last someone makes the case against localism
- Source: The Daily Telegraph
8th March 2010
The decentralisation of power is all very well, he argues. But what about things that are in the interests of the UK as a whole? What if we need a new rail-link, or a new power plant, or a new airport? Would every local council be allowed a veto?
The painful limits of localism
- Source: Tthe Guardian
7th March 2010
As the high-speed rail plans prove, the latest Tory attempt to distinguish between the national and the local is essential
Could a bigger airport actually make a greener Bristol?
- Source: BBC News
2nd March 2010
Can expanding Bristol's airport make the city greener?
David Cameron launches Tory plan to curb out-of-town developments
- Source: The Guardian
23rd February 2010
Local councils would be handed back powers to give them a greater say in stopping out-of-town developments under Tory proposals described by David Cameron as one of the biggest shifts in power in decades.
Conservatives launch Open Source Planning green paper
- Source: Conservatives.com
22nd February 2010
The Conservatives have released their Planning Green Paper, 'Open Source Planning'. The paper outlines proposals to use 'open source democracy' and neighbourhood involvement to encourage sustainable development.
Tories ‘don’t want a cosy deal behind closed doors’ on high speed rail
- Source: BBC Radio 4
19th February 2010
A cross-party consensus on plans for a new high speed rail link between London and Birmingham have been stalled after the Conservatives declined an offer from the government to look at the White Paper containing details of the route.
New-build homes: The road to nowhere?
- Source: The Times
12th February 2010
Planning issues rarely make it above health and education in the policy agenda, but a much-anticipated Conservative Green Paper, due for publication before the end of this month, could change all that. The Tories want planning decisions to be taken locally rather than by central government.
£100bn wind farm plan heralds green energy era
- Source: The Independent
9th February 2010
Revolutionary plans for a massive expansion of offshore wind farms have been unveiled in a £100bn project designed to usher in a new era of green energy for Britain.
Prince Charles and newts - your castle’s only hope
- Source: Daily Mail
7th February 2010
We want new jobs; but not a factory down the road or a windmill or aircraft noise keeping us awake. We poke fun at NIMBY – Not In My Back Yard – syndrome, but we are all NIMBYs. Planning is about striking a balance between expansion and conservation. There will never be a ‘right’ answer.
Laws that stop an Englishman from having his castle are insane
- Source: The Daily Telegraph
5th February 2010
Our refusal to allow enough new homes to be built is an attack on future generations, argues Charles Moore.
Conservatives vow to build Crossrail and “begin work” on high speed rail line
- Source: New Civil Engineer
4th February 2010
Shadow chancellor George Osborne has today pledged that his party will build London’s £15.9bn Crossrail scheme and start work on a north-south high speed rail line should they win the next General Election.
Wind farms can cause noise problems finds study
- Source: The Daily Telegraph
28th January 2010
The noise caused by wind farms can make some people ill, according to experts. The study by a panel of independent experts found that the irritation caused by the noise around wind farms can effect certain individuals. Scientists dismissed the idea of a "wind turbine syndrome" where the vibrations in the air or the particular sound waves from wind turbines cause headaches, nausea and panic attacks.
Infrastructure Planning Commission will never work if Tories win
- Source: The Times
28th January 2010
The Infrastructure Planning Commission (IPC) is unable to perform the task it was set, approving planning decisions for big energy and infrastructure projects such as nuclear power stations and high-voltage transmission lines, because the Government has yet to define the legal guidelines it should apply. Insiders say those criteria are unlikely to be approved before the general election and now the Tories have pledged to scrap the agency.
Benefits of new roads being overstated, say campaigners
- Source: BBC News
18th January 2010
The benefits of major road building schemes in England are being overstated by the government body responsible, a report has said.
Wind farms could blight one in six beauty spots
- Source: The Daily Telegraph
16th January 2010
One in six of the UK's officially-designated beauty spots could soon be blighted by wind farms, an investigation has found.
New UK offshore wind farm licences are announced
- Source: BBC News
8th January 2010
Successful bids for nine new offshore wind farm zone licences within UK waters have been announced.
Wind farms: Generating power and jobs?
- Source: BBC News
8th January 2010
Bids for tenders for nine zones around territorial waters and the Continental Shelf were submitted to the Crown Estate, which owns the seabed to a distance of 22.2km off the UK coast.
Controversial giant pylon plan approved for Scotland
- Source: BBC News
7th January 2010
Controversial plans for a line of giant pylons from the Highlands to central Scotland have been approved by the Scottish government. The upgraded, 137-mile line will see a network of 600 pylons, some more than 200ft in height, connect renewable power projects to the national grid.
Power line upgrade given go-ahead
- Source: BBC News
6th January 2010
Controversial plans for a line of giant pylons from the Highlands to central Scotland have been approved by the Scottish government.
Sun, wind and wave-powered: Europe unites to build renewable energy ‘supergrid’
- Source: The Guardian
3rd January 2010
It would connect turbines off the wind-lashed north coast of Scotland with Germany's vast arrays of solar panels, and join the power of waves crashing on to the Belgian and Danish coasts with the hydro-electric dams nestled in Norway's fjords: Europe's first electricity grid dedicated to renewable power will become a political reality this month, as nine countries formally draw up plans to link their clean energy projects around the North Sea.
High-speed rail link to rip up finest countryside
- Source: The Times
27th December 2009
A high-speed rail line from London to Scotland will cut through swathes of protected countryside under plans to be handed to ministers this week.
Limits on wind turbine noise too high
- Source: The Northern Echo
21st December 2009
Campaigners have reacted with anger to allegations that civil servants suppressed warnings over health problems caused by the noise from wind turbines. The revelation that current limits on wind turbine noise could be too high comes as planning authorities across the North-East and North Yorkshire consider proposals for more wind farms.
Planning applications must appear in local papers, government rules
- Source: The Guardian
21st December 2009
Local and regional newspapers have been thrown a lifeline after the government decided to safeguard £15m of local advertising. The advertising, in the form of planning applications, will still have to be published in local and regional papers, the government is due to announce today , despite a review recommending a relaxation of the rules.
Noise allegations could hamper wind farm plan
- Source: Accrington Observer
18th December 2009
A storm over noise pollution could throw a spoke in the wheel of a bid for a wind farm on Oswaldtwistle Moor. German-based wind development firm Energiekontor has finally submitted a planning application to erect a dozen 400 foot high turbines, over two years after first mooting the idea.
Rethinking NIMBY: Why Wind Power Could Lead To New Ways of Defining (and Dealing With) Public Naysay
- Source: Boing Boing
23rd November 2009
NIMBY - Not In My Backyard--is traditionally defined as what happens when people are, generally, in favor of something, but don't want the necessary infrastructure built anywhere they can see it. Bacon is delicious, but you don't want to live next door to a pig farm. Sustainable energy is great, but you don't want a wind turbine mucking up your views.
Go-ahead for 10 nuclear stations
- Source: BBC News
9th November 2009
The government has approved 10 sites in England and Wales for new nuclear power stations, most of them in locations where there are already plants.
Turn Nimbys to Yimbys on housing
- Source: The Guardian
29th October 2009
This year, fewer homes will be built in Britain than at any time since the second world war. Ministers will tell you that it's just a recession thing and that the moment the economy starts to recover they'll get back to delivering 3m homes by 2020
The New NIMBY-Defeating Wind Turbine
- Source: CleanTechnica.com
23rd October 2009
Ridgeblade is a fabulous wind-turbine solution from UK based The Power Collective. It’s very simple: instead of a large standalone windmill-like structure, put a long bladed turbine along the ridge of a building’s roof.
Nimby rural families ‘delay wind farms’
- Source: The Scotsman
21st October 2009
Rural communities anxious to protect their "chocolate box" scenery are delaying green energy initiatives in the UK, the former deputy prime minister said yesterday. John Prescott has called for councils to be obliged to locate a wind farm in their area.
‘Whisky’ wind farm rejected by one vote
- Source: The Scotsman
14th October 2009
Controversial plans for a giant wind farm straddling the hills between two iconic whisky-making glens on the edge of the Cairngorm National Park have been rejected. Infinergy, a Dutch renewable energy company, had lodged plans to develop a 59-turbine wind farm in the heart of Speyside at Hill of Dorenell on the Glenfiddich Estate near Dufftown.
Outrage as 400ft wind farms get green light
- Source: Rochdale Observer
14th October 2009
Fifteen 400-foot wind turbines will be built after controversial plans were given the green light. Government inspectors gave the go-ahead for two wind farms near Rochdale and Bacup, despite strong opposition from conservation groups and local planners.
Beyond the Backyard—The NIMBY of Today
- Source: RenewableEnergyWorld.com
8th October 2009
These days, the “backyard” in NIMBY has grown so vastly that residents often oppose airplane flight paths, offshore wind and liquefied natural gas terminals. More often it seems that NIMBY activists are simply in it to win it. They speak out, without taking the time to educate themselves with accurate information pertaining to the development at hand.
Back to business in Westminster
6th October 2009
MPs and peers have returned from the summer recess with the tough prospect of 11 government bills still waiting to complete their passage through parliament.
IPC now open for business
- Source: New Civil Engineering magazine
1st October 2009
The Infrastructure Planning Commission (IPC) has started work to an enthusiastic welcome from industry and business bodies. Chaired by Sir Michael Pitt, the IPC aims to drive down the time taken to process planning applications for large infrastructure projects to a maximum of a year.
Winning over the ‘Nimby blockade’
- Source: BBC News
30th August 2009
Developers of wind turbines and other energy schemes need to learn to work with - not against - local communities to get their plans approved, according to a new UK government study.
Getting over the nimby-ism hurdle
- Source: Financial Times
29th July 2009
Wind turbines have long been subject to criticism for ruining beautiful landscapes or creating noise. And local opposition looks like a growing problem for fledgling carbon capture and storage projects, too.
Not under our backyard, say Germans, in blow to CO2 plans
- Source: The Guardian
29th July 2009
Opposition to the carbon capture plan has contributed to a growing public backlash against renewable energy projects, raising fears that Europe will struggle to meet its low-carbon commitments. Last week, the Danish firm Vestas blamed British "nimbies" opposing wind farms for its decision to close its turbine factory on the Isle of Wight.
People in the countryside told to accept ‘many thousands’ of new wind turbines
- Source: The Daily Telegraph
16th July 2009
Country residents have been told that they must accept the building of "many thousands" of wind turbines as part of a new green energy strategy.
Ecotowns to get go-ahead despite local opposition
- Source: The Guardian
12th July 2009
An abandoned Norfolk airfield and a cluster of Cornish china claypit villages are to become the first of a controversial new breed of "ecotowns", offering thousands of new homes built within a cutting-edge eco-friendly community. The decision will be a blow to villagers who have campaigned against new developments at Rackheath, just outside Norwich, and St Austell in Cornwall.
Housing market Nimby nation: change in attitude needed for building more hom
- Source: The Guardian
8th July 2009
Britain must urgently change its attitude to building new housing if future boom and bust in the sector is to be avoided, a key advisory body warns today.
New national alliance to oppose wind farms
- Source: GreenWiseBusiness.co.uk
16th June 2009
Thirty local action groups opposed to the siting of wind turbines in their local communities have banded together to oppose what they describe as the "greenwash" of the wind industry.
Not in their back yards
- Source: Property Week
3rd June 2009
The end of the property boom has sparked a rise of protests against development. During the property boom developers have squeezed more and more on to their sites to make schemes viable. Now, the nimbys are fighting back and using the internet to bolster their campaigns.
Thames offshore wind farm gets green light from investors
- Source: The Guardian
12th May 2009
Scheme to build the world's biggest offshore project is approved by backers E.ON, Dong Energy and Masdar
Nimbys ‘thwart plans’ for cheap green energy
- Source: The Guardian
26th April 2009
Scotland risks being left behind in the race for green technology by an epidemic of nimbyism holding up planning applications and threatening to derail government targets for renewable energy.
The rise of Nimbys in Britain
- Source: The Times
13th March 2009
The majority of Not In My Backyard campaigns are against private residential housing schemes, a new survey indicates
NIMBYism in the West Midlands is becoming a growth industry
- Source: Birmingham Post
10th March 2009
It’s official; British attitudes are hardening. NIMBYism, the Not In My Back Yard ethos of protesting against new developments in their surrounding area, is on the increase according to a new piece of research.
Nimbyism ‘hardening’ in Britain
- Source: Planning Daily
9th March 2009
Planners face an increasingly difficult struggle to get public acceptance of development projects, according to an annual survey of public attitudes.
The Big Question: Is Britain finally on the brink of a high-speed rail revolution?
- Source: the Independent
24th June 2008
Network Rail yesterday announced it was looking at the feasibility of building five new high-speed main routes out of London to cope with soaring passenger demand.
Five key infrastructure developments were identified as central to Kent’s future regeneration: the extension of the High Speed 1 rail network to as far as Thanet; building a third Thames crossing on the lower Thames; the expansion of Kent International Airport at Manston; high-speed links to Gatwick Airport; and improvements to Dover port.